Common Mistakes Carnival Glass Collectors Make (and How to Avoid Them)

Collecting vintage carnival glass is a wonderfully rewarding hobby. The shimmering iridescence, the vibrant colors, and the fascinating history all combine to create a truly special collectible. However, like any collecting pursuit, there are pitfalls to avoid. This guide will highlight some common mistakes carnival glass collectors make and provide practical advice on how to steer clear of them.

1. Focusing Solely on Iridescence

While the iridescence is undeniably the most captivating feature of carnival glass, don't let it be your *only* criterion. The quality of the glass itself, the form of the piece, the rarity of the pattern, and even the manufacturer all contribute to a piece's value and desirability. A heavily iridesced but poorly made or common piece is often worth less than a less iridescent, but exceptional example of a rare pattern.

2. Ignoring Pattern Identification

Carnival glass patterns are numerous and sometimes confusingly similar. Rushing into a purchase without positively identifying the pattern can lead to overpaying for a common piece or, even worse, misidentifying a rare piece as something less valuable. Become familiar with pattern identification guides and resources. Compare the piece you're considering with known examples. Don't be afraid to ask experts for help.

3. Overlooking Damage & Repairs

Vintage carnival glass is, well, vintage. Chips, cracks, and repairs are common. However, the extent and type of damage significantly impact value. A small chip is generally less detrimental than a large crack or a poorly executed repair. Learn to identify different types of repairs (glue, fill, re-iridescence) and understand their effect on value. Consider the overall aesthetic impact.

4. Assuming High Iridescence Equals High Value

While desirable, strong iridescence isn’s always the deciding factor. “Rainbow fire” is often considered the most prized iridescence type, but other types like “gold fire” or “blue fire” are also sought after. The quality of the iridescence itself is also key – a vibrant, even iridescence is more valuable than a patchy or faded one. Pattern and rarity can often outweigh intensity of iridescence.

5. Neglecting Manufacturer Information

Knowing the manufacturer of a piece of carnival glass can be crucial for determining its rarity and value. While many pieces are unmarked, knowing the manufacturer—Northwood, Fenton, Imperial, Dugan, etc.—can provide valuable context. Research manufacturers and their associated patterns. This knowledge adds depth to your collection and helps you make more informed decisions.

6. Impulsive Buying

The allure of carnival glass can lead to impulsive purchases. Resist the urge to buy every piece you see! Take your time, research the pattern, assess the condition, and compare prices. A well-considered purchase is always more satisfying than a regretted one.

Conclusion

Collecting carnival glass is a journey of discovery and appreciation. By understanding these common pitfalls and taking the time to educate yourself, you can build a rewarding and valuable collection, and avoid costly mistakes along the way. Happy collecting!